A rear swingarm stand is a useful
item, whether your bike has a center stand or not.
I never owned a bike without a
center stand until my most recent purchase, a Triumph Thunderbird
Sport. Since I perversely get as much of a kick out of
working on bikes as I do from riding them, a method to hold the bike
upright for routine maintenance was a must.
Without a center stand, it's very hard to complete simple maintenance tasks,
such as fluid changes (oil, coolant, etc.), brake fluid flushing or
refilling and especially tire changes.
If you own a chain-driven bike,
it's about impossible to do any rear-end maintenance, such as a tire
change or chain adjustment without some way of holding the bike
upright.
My
center-stand-less bike experience meant that I had zero
experience with the swingarm-type rear bike stand. Most
people have probably seen photos in various magazines of race
bikes propped up on rear stands. But are they useful
in the real world?
It wasn't apparent to me how they actually worked -- it
appeared that race bikes had some type of fitting (called
"spools") on either side of the swingarm, and you
could slide one of these stands underneath and prop up the
bike.
The great news is that you don't need to have a special
race bike swingarm with spools to use a rear stand.
The Steel Horse Combo stand can be easily converted for
bikes with spools or for bikes that have conventional swingarms.
So now there's one more reason to buy
that track bike you were thinking about!
There are several stand
manufacturers out there, but the Steel
Horse Combo stand immediately caught my eye, because it appeared
to be of higher quality and generally a heck of a lot sturdier
than any of the other stands I've seen.
Some correspondence with Ken Englert and Aaron Abreu, co-owners of
Steel Horse Fabrications, convinced me that a lot of thought that
went into this product. Both Ken and Aaron are American
Federation of Motorcyclists (AFM) club racers, and it's obvious
that their experience provides a lot of input into their products.
For example, the black powder-coated finish (by Pacific Powder
Coating) on this Combo stand looks like it
could have come off of a show car.
I was actually afraid to use the
stand at first for fear of damaging the paint! Also, the
Steel Horse stands use 1.25 inch diameter steel tubing
construction, and the looped handle (vs. straight handles on some
stands) helps to prevent the user from tripping over it in the shop.
The Steel Horse Combo stand can be
used with spools or on normal swingarms without spools. The
spool receivers are made from stamped steel, and the saddles are
made from formed angle iron, featuring a forged and M.I.G. welded pin
for maximum strength.
A forging is much stronger than, for
example, some type of rolled steel, and the pin is a crucial
load-bearing point for the task of holding up your bike.
The saddles are also coated with Rhino Linings polyurethane -- the
same stuff you see advertised for heavy-duty use as a pickup truck
bed lining. This helps prevent the saddle from slipping
around on the swingarm when you lift the bike.
There's a quality detail that I didn't even notice until Ken
brought it to my attention: the holes for the cotter pin were
drilled vertically (rather than horizontally like some other
stands), because when you think about it, a horizontal hole
would weaken the pin as the weight of the bike pushes down on the saddle.
Ken told me that this feature has made the Steel Horse
saddles popular with owners of other brands of stands whose
saddles have bent due to over-extension.
We had a competing brand
of swingarm stand to use as a comparison with the Steel Horse
Combo stand for this review.
Now you'd think that bigger might be better, and that it might
offer more leverage when lifting the bike, but we learned an
interesting lesson here. Very subtle design changes can make
a big difference in not only the amount of effort it takes to lift
the bike, but also in determining how stable the bike will be when
it's on the stand.
For example, check out the diagonal
support braces on the black Steel Horse stand vs. the competitor's
stand in the photo on the left.
The Steel Horse's bracing
goes almost all the way up to the spool/saddle receivers, which
prevents flexing when the bike is being lifted and when the stand
is in use.
Strength is important, because sometimes you'll forget the bike is
on the stand at the most inopportune times -- like when you're up
by the forks grunting 70NM of torque on the front axle!
It's at times like that when you need a stand that will hold the bike
rock steady.
In fact, the design of
the competitor's stand meant that it could barely fit under the
TBird, and this bike has a pretty high fender, as you can
see.
The competitor's stand an acute lifting arm angle, which prevents the saddles from locating in a secure position up
under the swingarm. The saddles can only be placed at the
very end of the swingarm, under the axle and in a position where
they can easily slip back off.
The Steel Horse Combo stand is both smaller and lighter than the
competition, yet it is designed to fit well up under the swingarm
and securely against the flats of the swingarm to give a secure
grip for lifting the bike.
You don't want the saddles or
pins to be
hanging too far out over their receivers, as this will put a lot of stress
on the pin, rather than the stand.
The design of the Steel
Horse Combo
stand also gives it much better leverage than the competition.
The design angle of the tubes allows the Combo stand to fit much
farther up on the swingarm, which reduces the distance you have to
push through. And the Steel Horse's dual rear wheels make
lifting the bike a one-handed, anxiety-free operation. The
dual wheels provide 100% more surface area than single-wheeled
stands to spread the lifting load.
After using the competitor's stand, both my wife and I were really
surprised at how much easier it is to lift the bike with the Steel
Horse Combo. The Combo stand glides smoothly under the bike
and its arms don't flex, which
gives you a much more secure feeling when lifting the bike.
An ideal stand should be designed so that when you push on it, the
stand itself moves under the bike and lifts it in one efficient
motion.
The Steel Horse stand does just that -- you push down,
the stand smoothly rolls under the bike, and the bike lifts.
No drama. Steel Horse calls it their "E-Z Lift"
geometry, but whatever you call it, it works.
What you don't want is a stand that stays in one place and all your
effort has to go into levering the bike over the stand every time
you want to raise or lower it. Not only is this dangerous, it
can be back-breaking!
This is the case with the
competitor's stand. When you push down, the stand doesn't move
-- it tries to move the bike instead. Think about how much
effort it takes to one-hand a 450-odd pound motorcycle, and you get
the idea.
You also don't want the bike to be moving around when you're
lowering it by yourself. The farther the bike moves, the more of a chance
there is that the front wheel will start to turn slightly and move
the bike away from you in a direction that could be unsafe.
This is especially noticeable if you're trying to put the bike back
down on its sidestand -- you don't want the bike wandering one way
or another when your only grip is on the stand's handle. The
Steel Horse's ability to smoothly slide up or out from under the
bike makes a big difference in ease of use and peace of mind.
We took some measurements using each stand to see how far the bike
moved when lifting or lowering it. The Steel Horse moves the
bike only about 12". The competitor's stand takes about
16", which is 25% more. This may not sound like that
much, but believe me, when you're raising or lowering the bike by
yourself, it feels like a huge difference.
wBW
video demonstrating how to raise and lower a motorcycle
on the Steel Horse rear swingarm paddock stand.
We also found that the Steel Horse stand lifts the bike's rear tire
by a reasonable 2", which is more than enough to perform maintenance, and
low enough that it keeps the bike steady and secure.
The
competitor's stand lifted the bike by 3.5"; probably wasted
effort to raise it that high, and the bike did not feel as secure
when on the stand, both due to the height and the higher flex levels
of the un-braced arms.
The Steel Horse Combo stand works with swingarms from 12" to
14" wide. Spool setup can be adjusted in/out up to
1", and there are adapters for use with spooled swingarms less
than 13" wide.
The only complaint I have about the Steel Horse stand is that there
is no protection for the beautiful paint job underneath the
handle. When the bike is lifted and the back of the arm hits
the floor, you can scrape the metal
tubing, and eventually the paint could wear off. I'm going to
get a couple of self-stick rubber furniture bumpers and stick them
on the bottom of the tubing to prevent this from happening.
(NOTE:
Since this article was posted, Steel Horse has made a design change
and the stands will now incorporate stainless steel rivets on the
bottom of the arm to act as bumpers and which will protect the paint
from damage).
Using a rear stand can be a real lifesaver when working on your
bike, especially if you don't have a centerstand. But I don't
think think you should try and save a few bucks on what might be a
poorly designed and manufactured stand.
The Steel Horse Combo
stand is well-made and has been designed to perform, and also is
priced competitively. I think you'll find that once you start
using this stand, you'll wonder how you ever got along without it!
Product
Review: Motorcycle Rear Stand - Paddock Stand
by Steel Horse
Please
send
comments to
Comments are ordered from most recent to oldest.
From "C.L.B.": "I also purchased a
lift from Steel Horse fabrications based on the great review
written on your site. The device works as well as it is
described in your review and was accompanied by e-mail from the
owner of the company.
My device was even shipped out on a
Saturday! I even received some good advice about my
specific model of bike and how to make it more stable (given
that I have a dual set of pipes on both sides). This is a
fantastic product with great service."
From "P.S.": "After reading
the review on the Steel Horse rear stand I decided to purchase
one. I received it in about a week with a hand written
note plus a personal email thanking me for my purchase.
Talk about great customer relations. My stand also had the
rivets on the ground side to protect the nice powder coat.
Stand works awesome. Easy to use for a smaller guy.
Thanks for your great review and great site."
From "S.R.": "Just wanted to close the loop with
you and let you know that your reviews are seen and used. I
ordered the Steel Horse stand during the New Year holiday season,
and the response from the company was great—immediate communication
and immediate shipment.
Great workmanship on the stand,
including the addition of blind rivets (two) on the back of the
handle to protect the finish when the stand is in use.
As a
first time user, I found the stand remarkably easy and safe to use.
The leverage on the design makes it very easy to lift my Super Hawk
with one hand—really, easier to use than a center stand. As
you noted, it’s a lot easier to use a stand than it is to describe
the use of a stand.
Thanks again for your advice and good review and thanks to Steel
Horse for a great product and truly outstanding service."
From "D.L." : "Wanted to write
to let you know I purchased a swingarm stand from Steel Horse
Fabrications because of the review I saw on Web Bike
World. Fantastic build quality, extremely happy with it.
Incidentally, the stand did not have any protection on the
bottom (steel studs, etc.).
I saw you had mentioned they
might do that, so thought you might want to know in order to
update the page. I think I'll add some small adhesive
bumpers, because I have the same feeling as the author of your
review: Can't stand the thought of ruining that beautiful
powder-coat! Thanks for the informative website, and the
great write-up of this great product."
D.L. then wrote back: "Bought some 1" rubber furniture
bumpers (self-adhesive) today, that do the trick on the Steel
Horse stand (2 bucks @ Wal-Mart for about 20). I also
thought of using some 2" tire patches, and just gluing them
on. Decided to go the lazy route, and I think the bumpers
are going to work well. If you find some rubber tubing,
that might even work better, and I'd be interested to know where
you find it."