Bluetooth Intercoms
The
wBW
Motorcycle Bluetooth Intercoms Page
► See the wBW
Motorcycle Intercoms Page
for a listing of our motorcycle intercom reviews.
Motorcycle Bluetooth Intercoms
Finally! The simple Bluetooth wireless intercom
systems we wished for are here! Here are
two units that claim to meet our requirements of a
Bluetooth motorcycle intercom system that does NOT use a
cell phone or other intermediary "hub" device; thanks to
Jan from
MC
Sport in Denmark for sending us information on the
Cellular Line Interphone (Italy). See our review
of the
Interphone Bluetooth intercom
system, which is now available in the U.S.A., along with
all of our other reviews of wired and Bluetooth
motorcycle intercom systems on the wBW
Motorcycle Intercoms Page
What is Bluetooth?
Bluetooth is a short-range wireless communications
technology and standard for secure communications.
"The key features of Bluetooth technology are
robustness, low power, and low cost.
The Bluetooth
specification defines a uniform structure for a wide
range of devices to connect and communicate with each
other", according to the
Bluetooth Interest Group.
Stereo Bluetooth: These allow full stereo
connectivity to devices like the Garmin Zumo GPS system,
MP3 players, iPod, etc. See the
wBW
review of the IMC Camos stereo Bluetooth intercom system
| The
Parrot stereo Bluetooth device for motorcycles
transmits music and cell phone calls but doesn't appear
to be an intercom Convert Your Headphones or
Earphones to Bluetooth: Sony makes the DRCBT15
Bluetooth converter, available through this affiliate
link to Amazon.com (
Sony DRCBT15 Bluetooth Stereo Hands Free Mobile Phone Reciever/Transmitter
) that apparently
will convert a set of headphones to receive a Bluetooth
signal Motorola Wireless Helmet
Headset HS830: Many visitors have written to
us about this Bluetooth system. However, it
is our understanding from a conversation with Motorola
that 1) this unit still needs a cell phone as a base
unit and 2) the HS830 will be discontinued soon.
If you have more information, please send it to the
editor at the address above. Bluetooth Intercom Systems
► See the wBW
Motorcycle Intercoms Page
for a listing of our motorcycle intercom reviews.
-
Here's an interesting "Bluetooth
Pocket Repeater" (.pdf file) from AKE that looks
like it connects Bluetooth intercoms, radios, GPS
and other devices through a central hub.
-
The
Blue Bike (BlueBike) Bluetooth intercom is an
interesting sort of hybrid system; a control unit is
mounted on the motorcycle, which connects with an
MP3 player, FRS radio or other device. Then a
Bluetooth module is attached to the helmet, and this
module communicates with the mounted controller.
-
This Bluetooth intercom from
Dimton
is called the "BluVirtu" and features a Bluetooth
headset and microphone; this intercom is unique because
it is claimed to connect with and automatically switch
between a maximum of 3 devices at the same time,
including a mobile
phone, a radio transceiver, GPS or MP3 player
-
Yet another one,
but with a twist -- Nolan will apparently start selling
helmets with the
"N-Com" Bluetooth intercom system
-
Here's an informal survey
that lists various
motorcycle Bluetooth intercom parts, devices and
helmets that may work together
-
More
Bluetooth intercom enablers,
but I still don't see anything that will directly
allow two Bluetooth units to act as an intercom
without an intermediary device like a cell phone
Hybrid Bluetooth Intercoms:
The Intaride
Liberty Bluetooth motorcycle intercom apparently
needs a hub to be used as a rider-to-pillion intercom
but comes complete with two headsets, Bluetooth wireless
connectivity and a "pod" connector. Visitor "J.G."
writes "If you read the faq on their website you will
see that they are not Bluetooth, but are instead a
proprietary system that will only connect with their hub
which can in turn connect via cable to their intercom
box. It in turn can have a Bluetooth adapter
fitted which will allow connection to a phone for
example."
Bluetooth Motorcycle Helmets: Vemar has
a
Bluetooth capable motorcycle helmet that they claim
allows rider-to-pillion wireless communications |
The Vemar Bluetooth system is made by Stilo, which has
information about the system on their website
Interphone Bluetooth Intercom: See the
wBW
review of the Interphone Bluetooth motorcycle intercom
system. The
Interphone system was apparently jointly developed with
several manufacturers in Europe and the UK. It is
available through various retailers in the U.S.A., UK and Canada. Here's
a description sent by Moto Comp Ltd. in the UK: "We
have been developing the Interphone Bluetooth
Bike-to-Bike Intercom System with our Italian partners
for some time. We believe it to be the only full
wireless Bluetooth Intercom and phone System with true
Bike-to-Bike (up to 150 meters) capability in the world.
It is now ready for launch in the UK. We will be
launching to the UK trade at Motorcycle Trade-Expo in
January. We are very proud of the performance we
have achieved and are now looking for independent
evaluation. The product is completely
self-contained and comes with everything needed to fit
in any helmet in a couple of minutes.
Problems With Bluetooth Intercoms
Bluetooth technology still needs some work to make it user-friendly, in our
opinion. Bluetooth devices must be "paired" the first time they are
used. Pairing basically means that the devices swap some kind of
information to let them know that they should be communicating with each
other.
The instructions provided with all of the Bluetooth
intercoms we've tried so far are very poorly written and don't clearly
describe the pairing procedure; it's like the instruction manuals were
written by engineers and computer specialists rather than users.
What makes it more confusing is that the pairing procedure
doesn't always seem to work the same way twice. We've found this to be
the case with every one of the Bluetooth intercom systems we've tried.
Sometimes the two devices connect with each other as soon as
the units are turned on; sometimes we have to follow the instructions to get
them to "talk" to each other, and sometimes a different series of buttons
must be pressed to get everything to work. It's way more effort than
it should be, and the professionals tell us "it can't be done", but from the
consumer's point of view, two intercoms need only 2 controls: on/off and
volume.
The user should be able to turn on the devices and they
work. Instantly and without any fuss. Who cares about pairing?
All I want to do is talk! When I turn on a cell phone, I don't have to
press a series of buttons and wait for LEDs to light up in a particular
pattern as I try to negotiate with the carrier each and every time. I
turn it on, press a number and talk. Bluetooth intercoms should be no
different, and no different than a wired intercom system.
Our advice? We strongly recommend that 1) You copy the
owner's manual in your language and bring it with you. You'll need it! 2) Practice, practice, practice with these devices, both before they are
installed in the helmets and after. It's like a "black art" trying to
figure out which buttons to press in which order, what tones and beeps to
wait for, what the LED blinking lights mean...it's way, way too confusing!
Are Different Brands of Bluetooth Intercoms
Interoperable?
This question often arises when discussing Bluetooth intercoms. The
short answer is no. For the longer answer, HBC responds:
There is a growing awareness of the functionality and
capabilities of systems vis-ŕ-vis unique and common user
requirements.
Some developers and manufacturers understand the larger spectrum of
"communicating" and some don't...which is why we still have a wide choice of
single and multi-purpose systems available -- not a bad thing, just an
observation on a pretty healthy and competitive market.
To the best of my knowledge, Bluetooth communications between brands is not
possible, for many reasons, mainly marketing and sales based, as the
technology used in most systems is not the roadblock.
At this point in time, the solution is to find a system that supports the
use of common radio system (FRS/GMRS or CB or ??) between riders and/or
passengers. This option, while entailing some possible additional
investment in money and usually time to configure everything, is viable and
is used by many riders for group communications. The trick here is to
find a system that really can support the use of a commercial standard
common radio.
It is relatively easy to implement support for a radio via Bluetooth or as a
wired peripheral, but accommodating the individual switching and
transmission timings of so many different radios is the hard part. Any
company wanting to engineer in or support use of a common radio needs to
understand the personal communications parameters and requirements of the
respective market areas.
Building and qualifying a small set of interface cables to
serve a diverse range of radio sets is not a trivial thing, especially when
individual models built by the same manufacturer use different
specifications for switching, wiring, etc.
But with so many of the current leading systems implementing an interface or
actually offering up the necessary components (Midland is one example) and
given that so many coming-to-market systems have this feature engineered in,
there are more and more options all the time.
But, on the downside, many of the systems have not yet fully
developed specific or generic cables needed for the North American market,
something that most of the major wired system vendors have already dealt
with.
As I continue to research this issue, I should have a much better
understanding of if and how well the current group of Bluetooth
communications systems support a common radio capability and hopefully be in
the position to provide further insight into this known and growing
requirement.
There is an alternative, although it still involves the use of a common
radio or the walkie-talkie feature of mobile phones along with a headset or
ear-piece and microphone. I have used this on occasion using a bone
conductive headset (in-ear speakers and bone-microphone) and this works
well...a throat mike is even better.
And believe it or not, coordinated hand signals still works well and the
cost is reasonable. But, being able to chat, provide road and
condition alerts to the rest of the group and coordinate everything is just
so much easier, and safer with a communications system, rider to riders and
riders to passengers.
►Reader Comments and
Owner Feedback
Please
send
comments to
Comments are ordered from most recent to oldest.
Not all comments will be posted. Posted comments may be edited.
From "B.B." (5/09): "I own a Nolan N102 with N-Com and I
find it works really well. I have coupled it directly to my cell phone
with no problems and I also use it with my Tom-Tom Rider GPS.
The beauty of this system is I couple the N-Com to the GPS and the GPS to the
Cell phone. The Tom-Tom has a cell phone page where you can upload the
directory of the cell phone into the GPS and then make calls from the directory
from the GPS (but only while stationary; the Tom-Tom will not allow you to do
anything while moving except cancel a route, find the nearest gas station or
answer or reject an incoming phone call).
You can also pair two helmets together for intercom. The N-Com has
provision for a cable connection for auxiliary input, e.g. iPod etc, and also
for cable intercom if desired. I find the instructions to be
straightforward and the system easy to use."
From "M.D." (4/09): "After reading your product reviews on
the IMC Bluetooth and wiRevo products I am thoroughly lost. I own a Zumo 550, am
not interested in cell phone calls while riding, am not really interested in
talking to my passenger or another bike.
What I want is great stereo audio out of the Zumo, plus the turn by turn
instructions from the Zumo and into my helmet via bluetooth. What should I
purchase to get this done? Any advice would really help."
HBC's Response: With the zumo 550, only the wired output
jack will provide stereo audio, as the Bluetooth stream is mono only, although
the pending zumo 660 will rectify this in providing Bluetooth that supports the
A2DP (stereo) protocol).
Your requirements are basic and for about sixty percent of my riding time, the
same. To get good stereo audio out of the zumo, you will need a good A2DP
compatible Bluetooth adapter (BTA) – either of the IMC Camos BTAs used as part
of the Camos BTS 300 evaluation would do the job. Many other BTAs on the
market are compatible as well.
However, the zumo is not as ‘universal’ as some other devices in Bluetooth
operations, so it is very important to check compatibility and proper function
first. BTAs can range in price from well under $100 to well over 100 depending
on location and unit – their versatility however makes them a good deal,
especially over the long term.
Along with the wealth of information provided on wBW, there are
lots of other rider or user forums that will provide additional information
regarding compatible Bluetooth devices that work with the zumo…the list is
pretty extensive actually.
It is important to use an adapter that has Bluetooth 2.0 or 2.1+
or later – this will get you a very good A2DP (stereo) stream to your headset
and provides other advantages, such as faster connectivity, more stable stream
and power efficiencies."
Editor's Note: HBC is planning an article on
recommended solutions for various intercom uses, such as rider-to-rider,
rider-to-pillion, bike-to-bike and listening to GPS and music.
From "P" (4/09): "Hi, ( live in Southern California).
Just got a new DL650. This wild Bluetooth helmet to radio thing started
with the first ham radios with built in Bluetooth, made by Yaesu called an
FTM10SR. I installed it on my 07 DRZ400, paired it to an BlueAnt Interphone (I
tried several helmet BT systems but the Interphone worked the best).
The whole thing took me about 3 months to get dialed in due to poor support from
Yaesu. The radio had a remote tiny handlebar mounted waterproof head,
VHF/UHF/AM/FM entire police-fire scanner, and a plug in for a mp3. It was
low power,10 Watts VHF, 7 Watts UHF, but I was able to make over 100 mile
contacts ham to ham without repeaters (oh yeah, did I say these ham rigs are
modifiable for FRS/GMRS?).
I still own it. There are radios out there that can go on a bike that pump
some power out and don't need a license for (in the U.S.).
For those riders that want the following:
-
Want to talk to like-equipped
buddies (as many as the frequency can handle, which is a lot), not (just the
500 meter stuff either), more then a few miles or 20;
-
Want to talk on a radio that uses a
BT helmet setup;
-
Want something that does not look
like its the size of a cigar box pretending to be a FRS or GMRS thing your
actually supposed to attach to your helmet.
Here is what I did with the new bike and new off-the-shelf
system integration for 50 Watts VHF and 35 Watts UHF. It has a remote head
on the dash; the body of the radio is under the seat and the antenna is on the
back of the bike.
Of course I use an Interphone abd a Chatterbox XBI. Need
to be able to talk/listen to ham/FRS/GMRS/MURS, get GPS instructions, listen to
mp3 and have intercom.
But all this can be done with the XBI; I just like the way the
Interphone sounds when it transmits audio out of the radio. Interested in
the least?
New Bluetooth product out there boys and girls. New long
range communication for those that really want to reach out and touch someone,
and yes, unfortunately it will work with CB radios (that's a bad word around
amateur radio operators ha ha ha!).
I am not totally nuts. Was medically retired from the
police dept, am 43 with a 14 year old kid,a nd have a workbench full of
Bluetooth adapters and such. I am currently attempting to use a Jabra a210
generic 20 buck BT transceiver and mate it to one of my handhelds so my kid will
have something on her quad. I got a couple BT helmet sets lying
around......
OK, I started with a quad band (10 meters, 6meters, 2meters,
70cm),w hich most likely doesn't mean much to you.
It's called a Yaesu FT8900R. Suffice it to say that at
times, I will be able to talk worldwide from my bike, along with the VHF/UHF.
The radio has a remote head separated by a cable to the main body of the radio,
which I stashed under the seat.
The next really cool part is the "Talksafe" outboard
Bluetooth box. About the size of a pack of smokes. You feed it 12
Volts, plug one of its cables into the MIC jack of your radio, the other cable
coming out of it goes to the external speaker jack of your whatever radio, and
boom, instant Bluetooth radio.
Pair it up with most of the helmet systems (except the Blutek
built-in piece of *&^% radio), put a momentary switch or what we call a PTT on
the handlebars or in some cases hit the call accept button on the helmet and the
radio transmits. Hit it again and it unkeys, ready to receive.
Plenty of radios out there and good antennas, along with good BT
helmet systems that work absolutely bitchen when hooked to a ham radio (or
whatever radio) and this new Talksafe box.
I don't work for the company or anything, just trying to get
some fellow riders some decent comms. Here I am talking Bluetooth 100+
miles with the FT8900 ham rig and guys are saying a quarter mile is good.
WTF? HA HA HA .
My install is ultra clean including the custom fabricated remote
head bracket and fabricated rear antenna mount. I used a relay and have
the PTT on the horn. In 30 years of riding enduros, I have never used the
horn. Very usable system.
This system sounds much better then the original built in one on
the FTM10SR on the DRZ. Guys tell me they cant tell I'm on a bike! I
think Yaesu used a bad chipset with a lot of compression, clipping and gobs of
aliasing. Meaning it can sound kinda robotic, but totally usable.
Sorry if I have wasted your time with this. I have been a
ham operator for 24 years and according to the Talksafe company, RPF Industries,
it looks like i am the first to integrate this system on a motorcycle in the US.
They are in England. They also have units that plug into handhelds!
I'm just really excited at the comm possibilities with this system. The
box is like 189.00
The new 2009 DL650 is a mobile communications platform and
Disaster Assessment Vehicle for the Red Cross chapter I am on the Board of
Directors for, and Director of Communications (Antelope Valley Chapter in
Palmdale, California).
We handle 40 percent of Los Angeles County. Been a RC volunteer
for almost 15 years and am also an active instructor in First Aid/CPR/Disaster
Preparedness, and Earthquake survival. YES I LIVE 2 MILES FROM WILLOW SPRINGS!"
From "S" (10.08): "I have to agree with a couple of the
comments of your readers regarding wanting a unit I can use (with) my own mic
and earplug setup.
I've been considering getting a motorcycle intercom for the last couple of years
and been looking at the Bluetooth models in the aim of finding something
reasonable cost which allows me to use a throat mic and my Etymotic earbuds.
To me this is the ideal option, no need to worry about wind noise with a throat
mic (race teams use them) or the contradiction of trying to block out deafening
wind noise with earplugs yet hear music or voice from speakers.
With this setup it's not necessary to worry about what helmet it's connected too
because I don't need to worry about the helmet. Put the unit in my top
pocket with wires going to Velcro throat mic and up to ears for earbuds.
Requirements for weight, water proofing, small battery size become less of an
issue which helps manufacturing costs.
I was considering the scala teamset, now tending toward the
newly released Chatterbox ibx. But as biker ranted on another forum the
sellers provide very little information about the products on their websites
other than a pretty picture of the unit and packaging. Hope Chatterbox
give you the opportunity to review one of these units at some stage. Thanks for
a very informative site."
From "J.F.": "I've been reading your articles and product
reviews for a very long time now - thanks for all you do, by the way!
I have become so disenchanted with this whole subject for years.
Your list of "wants" for a Bluetooth system is dead-on. Why can't a
manufacturer just make this a reality? They would clean up. I would
be first in line to spend several hundred dollars, if only the unit does what is
in your list.
My son and I have actually been assembling components to make
out own device, but it is time-consuming and expensive if you don't do this for
a living.
My wife and I ride separate bikes and we have the Autocom units
- they work, but I feel like I'm strangled in all the freak'n wires and cables!
WE NEED TO CUT THE CABLES TO THE HELMET!!!
In 2008, it's hard to believe that this is a problem so hard to
solve! And, the manufacturers don't seem to get it. I called Autocom
last year basically outlining the system, and they acted like I was from Mars.
The guy wanted me off the phone so quick it was frightening. They are NOT
listening to what the customers are telling them.
Thanks for listening. At least you guys communicate nicely!"
From "T.Z" (Responding to our "Problems With Bluetooth Intercoms" above:
"Agreed! The problems we are trying to solve as consumers
are:
-
Get rid of the headset cable that
runs to the control unit.
-
Listen to MP3 music in stereo on the
headset
-
Create a list of paired devices that
automatically connect when turned on and in the same proximity and function
properly based on their purpose. The Bluetooth 2.0 specification
provides for up to 255 Bluetooth devices in each piconet (Bluetooth
network).
-
Be able to use the headsets as
Intercoms and use either speakers or earphones depending or preference with
separate volume controls.
-
Be able to listen to a shared music
source over the intercom. (Editor's Note: Music should stream from a
single source to both rider and passenger).
-
The various devices should interrupt
each other based on a prioritized connection scheme. Cell phones should
interrupt music and Intercom, radar detector should always be heard by the
rider but not the passenger.
-
Provide long lasting batteries that
run at least 20 hours that install in the helmet. This should not be
difficult as there are Li-Ion 3.7 volt batteries available for cell phones
that are small enough to fit in a helmet that are rated at over 2000mAh (Milli-Ampere
Hours) Most of the Bluetooth headsets operate at 4.5 (High end of a charged
battery) to 3.7 volts (Low end of an almost fully discharged battery.)
The batteries should either be swappable of there should be an option to
plug in an optional battery life extension pack in to the charging outlet of
the headset.
-
The devices should be lockable with
security codes that prevent unauthorized Bluetooth devices from joining the
piconet (Bluetooth network).
-
I don't care if I still have to plug
the GPS, radar detector, XM Satellite, etc. into the control unit. I
just want everything to talk to the headset over Bluetooth. The
control unit can handle all of the complex stuff such as port
prioritization.
There are a few more but that is my short list. I don't think
that is too much to ask."
From "C.J.": "Just been reading your
information on Bluetooth intercom/headsets. I bought a Motorola HS830 some time
ago and installed it in my Nolan N42 Jet. I use it with my Motorola L5
phone which I keep in a cradle on my handlebars. Thought I would let you
know that this system (about $120) DOES permit rider/passenger communication
without a cell phone. There is an 'a-b' switch on the back of the device.
Set one helmet to 'a' and one to 'b' and voila, there you have it.
Of course for bike to bike it's limited to Bluetooth range (30
feet) whereas the Interphone system will go 150. But for $120 bucks the
Motorola just can't be beat."
From GiMoto Canada: "GiMoto Canada Ltd. is
the approved Canadian distributor for the Cellular Line Interphone.
We first brought the Interphone (Euro power plug units) into Canada several
months ago and provided the units to several magazines within Canada, the
feedback has been amazing.
The key difference to the Interphone over other products
including the Scala Rider Team is the ability to use the Bluetooth intercom
feature from bike to bike! Cellular Line specifies the product has a range
of 150m at speeds up to 130 km/h. I have personally been at a greater
distance and had a clear conversation with the other rider.
See the
wBW
review of the
Interphone Bluetooth motorcycle intercom system.
Here
is a brochure (Adobe Acrobat format) on the
Interphone Bluetooth intercom and also an Adobe Acrobat version of the
Interphone Bluetooth intercom owner's manual.
From "M.E.": "I just read your comment about
the unavailability of rider to passenger Bluetooth intercoms. I too have
been scouring the internet, manufacturers and motorcycle dealers for such a
product...as have most of my motorcycle riding friends. It simply boggles
the imagination that such a beast seems not to exist yet. Even products
like the fairly new Chatterbox XB1, which was built from the ground up with
Bluetooth in mind and can communicate with other riders 5 miles away, can't
communicate with the person sitting 3 inches behind you without some sort of
wire going to them."
Comments? Send 'em to

|