|
Shoei Motocross Helmet
Shoei VFX-R Air Pastrana 2
wBW
Reviews Home
| Why does a motocross helmet have a different shape than a street
helmet? (answer below)
What's this? A motocross helmet in a webBikeWorld
review?
Hey, why not? We're always looking
for an excuse...or not...to buy some new gear, and the
new Triumph Tiger sitting in the garage gave us the
inspiration.
The popularity of Supermoto bikes with some of the local riders got us thinking about
using a motocross helmet on a street bike.
Well, not just any street bike -- after
all, an off-road helmet would probably look about as
goofy on a ZX-10R as it would a Fat Boy. But the
Tiger? Perfect!
The first thing we noticed about the VFX-R
-- other than the cool-looking graphics -- is the
weight. Or lack of it. At 1508 grams for a
size XL (3 lbs., 5-1/4 oz.), the VFX-R is one of the
lightest full-face (that's how we're classifying it)
helmets we've every tried. It uses Shoei's
Advanced Integrated Matrix Plus (AIM+) shell, just like
their best street helmets.
See the
wBW
Motorcycle Helmet FAQ page for a chart that compares
the weights of every helmet we've reviewed and you'll
see that the VFX-R is the third lightest size XL we've
tried. What's amazing is that even though our VFX-R
is a size XL, it's lighter than every other size large
helmet we've tried save two.
Now light weight isn't everything, but
it sure helps. We think that light weight makes a huge
difference in comfort, especially on a long ride.
Maybe I have sensitive neck muscles or something, but
heavy helmets are (literally) a pain, especially when
riding in cross winds or behind one of those "Buffet-meister"
fairing designs.
Light weight can be a sign of scrimping
on the helmet's safety features, but the VFX-R is both
DOT and Snell approved. I would think that the
protruding motocross chin would make up for the weight
lost in the big, wide eye opening, so I'm not sure where
all the weight was lost. Which begs the question: why
aren't other full-face helmets as light as this?
I'll admit that I've never worn a real,
live, dedicated motocross helmet before, so I'm an
absolute tyro when it comes to this type of gear.
Sure, I've bounced around on dirt bikes, but never
enough to justify digging deep enough in my pockets to
buy focused dirt gear. And since we've never tried
anything similar, I have no idea if the light weight of
the VFX-R is normal or an aberration in this market.
Frequent webBikeWorld visitors will know
that a couple of us have "earth" shaped heads (again,
see the
wBW
Motorcycle Helmet FAQ page to learn more about
different head shapes and fitting a motorcycle helmet),
which frequently give us helmet fitment problems.
The most common headform used by the helmet
manufacturers seems to be the "egg" or "long
oval" shape, that is, wider on top, narrower on
the sides.
So when we find a helmet that fits a
round or earth shaped head, we're golden. As soon
as I slipped the VFX-R over my noggin, I was in heaven.
This is probably one of the most comfortable fitting
helmets I've ever tried, which I find amazing. I
just didn't expect it!
The size XL fits me perfectly, and the
fit is helped by the nearly unlimited chin room afforded
by the motocross-style chin (I'll show my ignorance here
about all things dirt: why do motocross helmets have
such a big chin? Let me know at
and I'll post the answer below in the "Comments" section).
The VFX-R is to chin room as scoring an
exit row seat is to an overseas plane trip. It's
great! The design not only frees up the space in
front of my mouth, it also provides more freedom around
my cheeks, which often feel crunched inside all but the
earthiest of earth-shaped helmet interiors. I can
literally wear this helmet all day long and feel
perfectly comfortable.
So the fit, combined with the light
weight, makes the VFX-R one of the comfiest helmets I've
ever tried. So far, so good...
Wearing a motocross helmet means using a
good pair of goggles, and my experience in this neck of
the woods is also zilch. I did some research and
talked to my dirt and Supermoto riding friends, who
recommended the Smith Option OTG Airflow. This
goggle was specifically recommended because it's
designed to fit over eyeglasses, and it's also designed
to provide enough air flow to prevent fogging.
The eye opening on motocross helmets are
nice and wide for a reason. The goggles are
designed to fit inside the eye opening (the area
normally covered by a visor on a full-face street
helmet), and the strap fits around the back of the
outside of the helmet. The 33 mm wide strap on the Smith
goggles have some nice silicone strips that give it a
good grip on the helmet's surface and prevent the strap
from riding up over the top of the round helmet shell.
I had a problem locating this exact
Smith goggle model, but I finally found a pair at
RideGear.com (see the
wBW
quick review of Smith Motocross Goggles). The
Smith goggles fit perfectly over my eyeglasses and they
are very comfortable because they have a very thick foam
cushion. The only problem is that they press
against the bridge of my nose, making it slightly
difficult to breathe
and giving me a feeling like I have a mild head cold.
This can be somewhat mitigated by loosening up the strap
as much as possible to relieve the pressure, but the
strap can't get too loose or it may not hold the goggles in place.
It takes a while to get used to riding
with goggles, because their thickness means that
peripheral vision is somewhat diminished. But it
didn't take me long to reorient myself, and the
combination of the motocross helmet and goggles doesn't
really feel that strange.
And there is a definite benefit to that
big, wide opening in the front of the helmet -- plenty
of fresh air! I get pinged once and a while on the
few parts of my skin that are exposed between the
goggles and the helmet's shell, but other than that,
it's great (at least in the currently warm riding
weather) to have all the ventilation I'll ever need.
The VFX-R has a couple of intake vents
in the brow, underneath the removable visor, and two
exhaust vents out back. There's also a vent in the
front of that big chin, with its own foam dust filter.
But it's impossible to tell if the vents are working,
and they don't really seem necessary, at least during
street riding speeds, because that big, wide opening
allows all the air that's needed to keep cool.
The downside of the big opening and all
that air flow is noise. We always wear properly
inserted earplugs when riding, and all of our helmet
reviews are conducted whilst wearing earplugs and a
helmet liner. See the
wBW
Earplugs and Hearing
Protection page for more information on finding,
fitting and wearing earplugs. We strongly recommend
that you always wear earplugs when riding motorcycles so
that you don't end up partially deaf with a bad case of
tinnitus like me...
Ironically, the motocross shape of the
VFX-R seems to eliminate the low frequency buffeting
from windscreen spillover. There's lots of wind
rushing noise, but no matter how hard I try, I can't
duplicate the annoying "booming" sound that is so common
when turbulent air hits the bottom of a full-face helmet
and bounces around inside.
The motocross style visor doesn't affect helmet
buffeting as much as I thought it would. If I tilt
my head back, the air will catch under the visor and
lift the helmet, but it really isn't that bad, at least
at the speeds I run. I've used full-face street
helmets that have as much or more lift than the VFX-R.
The Shoei VFX-R is available in solid
colors and a couple of cool-looking graphics. We
really like the Air Pastrana 2 version, which carries
all of Shoei's high standards of quality in every
feature. The helmet's motocross visor must be
assembled, but it easily screws in to the top of the
helmet (we used a butter knife as a screwdriver!).
The liner material is very comfortable,
just like Shoei's best street helmets, and it's
removable, along with the cheek pads and even the strap
covers. The chin or nose cover is attached with a
tiny screw that can be removed to clean the dust filter.
We're not sure why the chin cap wasn't designed to snap
on and off, because it seems like it would be pretty
easy to lose the screw.
Conclusion
Riding the Tiger with the VFX-R is a definite trip.
It feels cool (literally and figuratively) and the image
of a rider with motocross helmet and goggles but wearing
full street leathers and race boots must give people a
kick, because I swear I get more stares and waves when
wearing this helmet than any other outfit I own.
Little kids seem to love it -- I'm not
sure if it's because they recognize Travis' helmet
colors (I doubt it), but they always point and wave, and
lo and behold, even the cruiser riders who almost never
wave when I'm wearing a full-face street helmet seem to
open up at the site of "Supermoto Man". It's a lot
of fun and fits the rugged image of the Tiger perfectly!
Some of the issues with the VFX-R include the
cost, the
noise and the fact that goggles must be worn. The VFX-R's list price
is $579.99, which seems excessive, but the street price
is somewhat lower. I can't do anything
about the noise, but I'll try different brands of
goggles to see if I can find one that fits over my nose
with less interference.
If you own a BMW GS, Triumph Tiger, KTM
Adventurer or other cross-functional motorcycle, check
out the VFX-R and complete the look.
Note: For informational use only. All material and
photographs are Copyright © webWorld International, LLC - 2001-2008. All
rights reserved. Read the
Terms and Conditions. See the webBikeWorld®
Site Info
page.
| Product
Review: Shoei VFX-R Motocross Helmet |
| Available
From:
Shoei Helmets |
Street Price: $467.99 (List
price $479.99) |
| Colors: Black, White and several
patterns. |
Made
in: Japan |
| Product
Comments: Well made, high quality, comfortable fit for round
shaped heads. DOT and Snell approved. I believe the VFX-R is
known as the "Holeshot" in Europe, and is ECE 22-05 approved.
Comfortable and removable liner. Noisy due to wide opening for
goggles. |
|
More:
Motorcycle Helmets page |
600x525 pixel photo of the Shoei VFX-R Air Pastrana 2 |
Arai XD Review |
Airoh S4 Review
| MX
Training Journal - Plan and document most everything that has to do
with practice and follow the development in the form of statistics and
diagrams. |
Comments on This Article
Why the Big Chin?
Ever wonder why off-road helmets have such a weird chin shape? So did we.
A
wBW
visitor did some sleuthing and found two good reasons.
The question was: "Why do off road helmets have such a protruding chin guard?
I'm curious if you can offer any insights into how the off road or MX helmets of
today developed such a different shape as compared to street helmets."
From "H.R.": "I
did a little research in the web and found
this page that has a lot of information about off-road riding, check it out.
What I can tell about what I found is
that the big pointed chin bar design is stronger to withstand hard impacts from
rocks and other flying things and to allow more ventilation. Just look a
motocross race and you will see that they move more and make more physical
effort in the jumps, turns, etc. than a road racer. With that amount of
sweat and hot air in the helmet try to vent it with a road helmet, it is going
to be a hard time.
Note: In physics two geometrical
shapes that withstand a high amount of mechanical effort or pressure are the arc
and the triangle. In these case a front impact from a rock, will hit a
motocross helmet in the tip of the chin bar, a small strong area, (and not a
entire arc) that with the triangle shape will distribute the impact force to the
whole helmet structure more effectively than a arc shape would do, preventing an
early chin bar destruction.
The other thing, the triangle shape
design of the chin bar does, is that deflects or changes the direction of the
flying rock diminishing the force of the impact in the helmet."
Thanks - this makes very good
sense!
From HJC: "The two different shell types (i.e.,
street vs. off-road) are optimally designed for the different recreations
because neither sport has the same safety characteristics. The speeds
differ from street riding to MX riding, hence the design of the shell for street
use is different from that of MX. The reason why the street helmets' chin
bars are closer to the chin is because of aerodynamics - less space between the
chin and chin bar means less air turbulence. Also, on the MX helmets, the
bigger gap leads to more air travel, which helps a lot because you are riding
much slower than on the street, requiring more air to feel more ventilated."
Makes sense! And so does this answer:
"Because you move around so much the lower part of your face
(jaw) needs clearance and the air flow to your mouth is better. Also, when you
crash, the chin guard has some give in it and will absorb impact without
injuring the jaw."
|