|
Triumph Thunderbird Sport Air Filter
Change
More: The wBW
Maintenance and Repair
Article Index |
Comments From Visitors
(Below)
I've
done a lot of motorcycle maintenance in my time, but replacing the
air filter on my 1999 Triumph Thunderbird Sport probably ranks as one of
the most frustrating mechanical experiences ever.
It even beats
the wacko oil filter change on the oil-cooler equipped BMW R100RS, which
involves radical contortions and special tools and took me 4 hours after
I finally removed the right hand exhaust.
Something as simple and routine as an air
filter change should not take more than, say, 1/2 hour? I can
change the air filter on both my BMW Airheads in less than half that
time.
So unless someone clues me in to the
secret of the TBS air filter change, I'm going to rank it as one of the
most bonehead engineering decisions that Hinckley-flavored Triumph has
made on an otherwise very nicely designed motorcycle.
If anyone
has any tips on making this job easier or can point out any mistakes I
made, please feel free to send them to
me at and
I'll add them to this article for the benefit of others.
The problem is indicated by the yellow
arrow in the photo above: the front airbox on the TBS is a one-piece,
U-shaped design that wraps around the chassis backbone.
After
scratching my head and trying everything I could think of, I could not
figure out a way to get the airbox out from around the backbone without
first removing the carburetors.
I guess Triumph had its reasons
for this design, but it sure seems to this armchair engineer that there
could have been several other ways to locate the air filter which would
have made this job much easier.
For example, the right-hand
side of the air filter chamber, indicated by the white arrow above,
could have been designed as a separate piece with a couple of clips to
unfasten a section of plastic and access the filter. Pop the clips, slide out the
air filter, slide in a new one and you're done.
Alternatively,
the air filter could have been located in the rear airbox (pink arrow,
photo left), which has the snout for
the air intake (the air intake snout is located on the right side of the
bike, in back of the battery and not visible in this photo).
This airbox is located under the seat and is easy to access.
Air flows in through the snout and into
the primary airbox (pink arrow), then through the tube and gasket
(red arrow) connecting the two airboxes, then into the front airbox
(green arrow), and finally through the air filter, which lives at the
intersection of the front airbox and the air filter chamber that attaches to the
carbs. The tip of the green arrow indicates the location of
the air filter.
To make things more confusing, the
routine maintenance section of the Haynes manual refers the reader to chapter 4 for
airbox removal. Chapter 4, section 16 of the Haynes manual details
removing the airbox but never says that the carbs have to be removed
first.
I suppose an argument could be made that Haynes steps you
through removing the carbs in the beginning of chapter 4, so by time you
get to section 16 the carbs should already be out. I sure missed
this the first time around.
I'm probably ranting here, but I would
think that since you may have arrived at section 16 in chapter 4 from the routine
maintenance section with only a desire to replace the air filter and not
remove the carbs, that at least
Haynes should have mentioned that you'll need to remove the carbs before
you can remove the airbox.
I spent a lot of time and effort
wondering why I couldn't get the airbox out by following the Haynes
instructions, until I realized that the carbs have to come out
first. Maybe I'm a bit slow on the pick-up, but hopefully this
will save someone else a headache.
By the way, besides a set of long hex
wrenches or hex bits, a long screwdriver and a 10mm socket or wrench (to
remove the fuel tank bolts), you'll need size T25 and T30 Torx bits to
do this job.
You'll need to really reach in there to loosen the carb hose clamps, so it definitely helps if you have the screwdriver bits,
the hex bits and the Torx bits all ready to use on a long-handled bit
driver. See the wBW
review
of the Wiha bit driver, which is an excellent tool for this job (no
connection with Wiha other than a satisfied user).
Anyway,
you'll first have to remove the fuel tank (see the wBW article on TBS
coolant changes for instructions on how to do this).
Make sure the carbs are drained before you
start this job; you can do this by closing the fuel tap and running the
engine until it's out of gas before you remove the fuel tank. Be really careful during this
project, as you're likely to spill some fuel here or there.
You'll need to remove the chrome "air
filter" trim on each side of the TBS and also the black plastic
fluted covers. Follow the Haynes manual for how-to's (chapter 4) on this and
you should be ok.
The primary (rear) airbox under the seat has to
come out. To do this, you'll have to first remove the left side
"battery" cover. This rear airbox is attached at the
bottom by the same 5mm hex screw that
holds the side cover. The airbox is held on top by a Torx screw
that threads directly into the soft plastic of the airbox (another strange
piece of engineering).
The airbox hangs on a frame-mounted pin that I'm
pointing to in the photo. You have to pull the airbox
towards you to get it off this pin. I had a lot of trouble with
this pin when I was putting things back together, as we'll see below.
By the way, Haynes suggests removing the seat lock, which is attached to
this rear airbox, but I didn't find
this to be necessary. The Triumph shop manual advises removing the
horn and the cables from the carburetors. I didn't do either of
these and don't think it's necessary.
Also -- there are two vent hoses that come
out of the carbs; make sure you remember how these are routed over the
top of the airbox and chassis spine. I believe these hoses allow the
chambers on top of the carb diaphragms to equalize with external air
pressure. I don't think it's that important where the vent hoses hang, as
long as they're not pinched.
Once
you get the rear airbox off (a relatively easy task), you'll have to loosen
all the hose clamps that attach: 1) the secondary airbox to the carbs
(3mm hex); 2)
the hose clamps that attach the rubber hose to the front of the carbs
(screwdriver) and; 3) the hose clamps that attach the hose to the engine
(screwdriver) intake tubes.
All of these hose clamps are indicated by the yellow arrows in the
photo left.
Hopefully whomever did this the last time located the
screws for the clamps on the middle carb in a place that allows you to
reach them!
Once you get all the hose clamps
loosened, it's fairly
easy (or was, at least on my bike) to pull the U-shaped airbox back and separate
it from the air filter chamber. This provides a tiny bit of wiggle
room to rock the carburetor rack back and forth to loosen the carbs from
the short lengths of hose that run between the air filter chamber and
the intake tubes.
It's a real pain to get the three short hose sections
out from in
between the carbs and the engine's intake. It's a matter of
pulling, pushing, cursing, resting and trying it again until they come out.
Note that the hoses that fit between
the carbs and the engine intake tubes are a one-way fit. The end that
attaches to the airbox and the end that attaches to the intake tube is different. The hoses are wider at the top than at the bottom to
locate the carbs correctly. Make note of how the hoses are located
before you rip them out.
Once you have the carb rack loose, you
can then remove the entire rack out the left side of the bike. I asked
my wife to help out by holding the carbs off to the side while I then
removed the breather hose from the bottom of the air filter chamber and
finally slipped the air filter chamber and the U-shaped airbox out from the chassis.
Once you have the airboxes out you can lay the carb rack roughly back
where it came from. Be careful not to bend or kink the choke or
accelerator cables. Again, the Haynes manual does a decent job of
explaining everything in chapter 4. I suppose it would be a good
practice to balance the carbs after they're put back in; I didn't do it
this time and the bike seems to run fine, but I will balance them during the winter and I'll write it up.
Here's
a photo of the U-shaped airbox (upside-down) and the air
filter. The yellow arrow points to the barely visible
engine intake tubes where the hose attaches, and the pink arrow
shows the carb rack laying in the chassis.
There are 10 Torx screws that
hold the air filter chamber on to this U-shaped airbox.
Triumph claims that the air filter is not available separately and that
the entire airbox assembly must be purchased.
This is strange, and
I bet it's because they don't want you to know that you can probably get
away with cleaning the existing foam filter, thus depriving them of some
revenue. Obviously, I was able to remove the Torx screws and
access the filter without having to purchase the entire airbox assembly.
The previous owner told me he
installed a K&N air filter, but this air filter isn't a
K&N, so I don't
know what he meant. TBS riders tell me this is the Triumph
stock filter. It's a foam filter, not paper, and although
Triumph recommends replacing it and the entire airbox chamber (not sure why), by time I got this far the Triumph dealer
wouldn't be open for a couple of days, so I washed the filter with
dishwashing liquid and gave it a light coat of oil and put it
back in. Other than some grass and dust, it was in pretty
good shape, so I figured I'd be ok.
You probably think I'm nuts to go through
all this and then put the old filter back in, but I honestly thought
this would be a 1/2 hour job and that I could see how everything came
apart and then put it back together and ride over to the dealer to get a
new filter, then come back and do it again and record it for posterity.
I'm not sure what the white stuff
is -- it appeared to be some silicone sealant that was only
placed on the bottom lip of the box. I don't know why it's
there or who put it there. I didn't replace it,
and the box seemed to seal up fine. After I got everything
back together (reverse order), I started up the bike and gave it
the old "contact cleaner" test.
I sprayed some
contact cleaner around all the potential cracks in the box and
the around where the hoses meet the airbox and engine to see if
the idle changed or if there was any smoke from the
exhaust. If so, it's a good indication that there's a
leak. This is a dangerous test, so be careful and do it in
a well-vented area. There's a chance of fire, so do it at
your own risk. Don't use any flammable sprays or anything
that could harm plastic, paint or rubber. I didn't notice
any leakage.
Putting
everything back together was just as much of a pain (or more) as
getting it apart. I struggled for a considerable amount of
time to get the hoses and clamps and carburetors located in the correct
orientation and to get everything buttoned back up. Again,
it's a matter of brute force and patience.
I strongly recommend taking
several long breaks during this job, as your
patience will be severely tested, and it pays to come at it with a fresh
approach now and then. Why it should be so difficult just to replace an
air filter is beyond me.
Make sure the hoses and clamps are
located correctly; that the hoses aren't pinched; and that the hose
clamps will do their job of sealing everything up.
After I got the carbs back in and
the U-shaped airbox buttoned up, I had a lot of trouble getting
the rear airbox correctly lined up in the frame. It had
obviously been brute-forced in place at the factory, and now I
couldn't (wouldn't) use the same force to get everything back
together.
There's a tab
that's welded on to the TBS's frame up top that locates the Torx
screw mentioned earlier that screws directly into the top of the
plastic
airbox. That tab apparently was welded out of location on
my bike, because it was impossible to line up the screw that
goes through that tab, the
pin that holds the airbox (mentioned earlier), the hex screw on
the bottom of the airbox that also holds the left side
"battery" cover and the two snouts
(shown in the out-of-focus photo above, sorry!).
These two snouts were too long
and interfered with each other and were causing the misalignment
problem. I ended up trimming them back with
a Dremel to get everything to fit correctly. Before I put the hose and clamps back on I took
this photo to show that they are still out of alignment, but
they are now much better than before.
I bet there's a potential for a
loss of horsepower on my bike because the air can't get cleanly
through from one airbox to another. If I didn't know any
better, I'd bet that Triumph found out late in the design of the
TBS that the airboxes had to be re-engineered, possibly to meet
noise regulations. The entire design of the airbox
assemblies and the air filter seems to be not very well thought
out.
Addendum: Right Side Cover Interference Solution
When
I took off the right side cover at the beginning of this
project, I noticed that it rubbed
against the black plastic fluted trim section (photo
left).
It was starting to scratch the paint, and this
cover comes off much more frequently than the left side cover,
so I was afraid that it would eventually rub off all the
beautiful yellow paint.
The photo below shows the
scratches in the paint (left photo). I had a few pieces of
3M Scotchcal around, so I installed a piece at the rub point to
help protect the cover from any more damage.
Scotchcal is great stuff to have around. It's a clear
plastic sheet that is used to protect paint from chips.
It's used a lot in the automotive industry. See the wBW
review of a Scotchcal protection kit
for a BMW R1150RT to learn more about this product.
Scotchcal is very easy to install once you get the hang of it -- just
spray on a mixture of water and a touch of dishwashing liquid
and slide the Scotchcal on like a decal. Locate it in the
correct spot and squeegee out the water and let it dry.
The photo on the right below shows the side cover now protected
by the Scotchcal sheet. Scotchcal dries clear and you
usually don't know it's there unless you look for it. It
peels right off if necessary and doesn't harm the paint, but it
protects it from scratches. I use it on all my bikes in
areas where there may be stone chips or frequent rubbing from
pants, jackets, zippers, etc.
Do a wBW
search for "Scotchcal" to locate sources for
the material; I bought a bunch from a guy on the Triumph T5.net
list.
 |
 |
| Side
cover before; note the scratches. |
Side
cover after; note the scratches now covered by the
Scotchcal. |
Comments From Visitors
From "K.H.": "Just read
your article on the Trumpet airbox. I have had two Trophy
1200cc fours (still got one) and they are just the same.
I tried to cut out the end of the box and slide the old
filter out- no chance. What I did learn was that when
you put the carbs back on make sure that the jubilee clip
screwdriver slots face up. This makes removal a lot
quicker next time. I also removed the rubber sleeves
to the carbs prior to sliding the carbs out of the way.
You can do it with them on but it is a real pain.
Got to say the Trophy is a real comfy bike.
We have just done a fund raising run for UNICEF from the UK
to Kiev, 4,000 miles in twelve days. The wife and I never
got saddle sore even when riding 12 hours a day."
From "B.K.": "I have a
2000 T-Bird (not the sport). Your article took the
mystery out of this job. I was actually done in about
2 hours, but that was because I knew exactly what to do.
My filter looks exactly the same as yours, so I just sprayed
it out with brake cleaner and the filter looks brand new.
My air cleaner housing had the same silicone sealant on the
bottom half only of the box. I know this assembly has
not been touched, so these must be factory installed.
Re-installing was a snap (thanks for the tip on the carb to
engine couplings, I carefully marked them so I would not put
them in backwards).
I did find a really weird thing. There
is a hose at the bottom of the air filter housing on the
backside, and it actually tore off as I was removing the
housing. I inspected it, and found it to be extremely
soft and squishy. Then, I discovered a part of the
hose that felt rock solid. As I pinched on it, I felt
something move, so I kept squeezing until a rubber nipple
came out the end of the hose! I'm guessing the nipple
blocked the drain and so the hose soaked up the oil, or
something. Ever hear of anything like that?"
Airbox Hose Question Solved?: This
from "K.G." - "I have just read your how to guide on removal
of a Triumph airbox. I am sorry to say, that I can not
improve on your description. Though I can gleam some light
on the squidgy tube which is attached to the bottom of the
air box.
There is a larger diameter engine breather
tube, which connects the top of the crank case to the bottom
side of the air box. Over time small amounts of fluids from
the engine build up in the base of the airbox. The small
tube is there to drain this fluid. Triumph recommend
draining the fliud every 3,000miles. The hard lump is just a
bung. I hope this explains the squidgy tube.
I am not a mechanic and this information was
gained when I was diagnosing a problem on my Legend. If the
seal on the breather tube fails, you will find small amounts
of oil from the engine sucked up the breather tube. After
about 500 miles, the oil will build up in the air box. In my
case, the oil started to seep out of seam of the air box."
From "B.P.":
"Hi Rick, I have a 1996 Triumph Sprint that I
recently purchased. I had to replace the cracked
air box. My neighbor, who owns a Triumph Tiger,
thought that I would have to remove the carbs to access
the box and offered to help me. I am definitely
not a mechanic, but nor am I mechanically insane.
On Sat. morning at 6:00, I logged on to the internet and
searched "Triumph Motorcycle Air Filter
Replacement" and to my amazement, your article was the
very first that I encountered. Though it was for a
different year and model of Triumph, it took me exactly
through the step by step process to correctly replace
the air box. It did take me about five hours to
complete the task.
I do agree that this was a
stupid design by Hinckley and the armchair engineers.
When my neighbor called me on Sat afternoon and offered
to come and help, I told him that I had the job done
thanks to your article. I just thought I would send you
a quick email thanking you for the great information."
|