Summary The GoPro HD video camera takes very good
quality HD video and decent photos. It has several interesting features,
but the menu system seems obsolete compared to the Drift X170 (see
Part 2 of this review). The GoPro HD
is slightly bulky for use on a motorcycle.
Combine the best features of the Drift X170 and the GoPro HD and you'd have a
winner.
Background
It's not often that we have two items at the same time
to compare for a review, but the GoPro HD and the Drift X170 video cameras
arrived within days of each other, making a comparison a natural.
I am the evaluator for both of these cameras and I decided to write two separate
reviews, but I will compare each camera when appropriate and summarize my
opinions within each review.
So let's start with the GoPro HD Hero video camera. Actually, this is the
"Motorsports" version of the GoPro HD. The company also makes
"Surf Hero" and "Helmet Hero" versions, but the Motorsports version is usually
the version sold for motorcycle use. Any of the GoPro HD cameras can be used
for any of the other configurations by purchasing accessory mounts, but the
basic camera is the same no matter which configuration you choose.
The original GoPro camera was
reviewed on webBikeWorld, as was the
GoPro Wide, which
was apparently a pre-HD attempt at getting an HD-like camera to market.
The Drift X170 that I'm reviewing in
Part 2 is not HD; it is also a wide format camera, making this comparison a bit of an
apples-to-oranges exercise, but both cameras have their pros and cons.
I'll cut to the chase here and say that a camera that combines the form
factor and menu system of the Drift X170 with the HD quality of the GoPro HD
would be the real winner here, but no such camera currently exists, which is
unfortunate.
GoPro HD Specifications
The GoPro HD is a full HD video camera, recording 1080p in H.264 format at
1920x1080 pixel resolution and either 30 or 60 frames per second. The 60
fps files will display as slightly slow motion (standard filming is
approximately 30 fps). It will also take 720p at 1280x720 and 960p at 1280x960 by choosing the format in the menu system.
The GoPro HD will also take 5 megapixel photos in single mode or it can be set
to take a photo every 2, 5, 10, 30 or 60 second intervals, along with a 3-photo
"burst" and it has a self-timer. Photos and video are stored on an SD card
up to 32GB capacity and the files are .MP4 format (H.264).
Average claimed recording times card are 12 minutes per GB for 1080p; 13
minutes per GB for 960p and 16 minutes per GB for 720p. So multiply one of
those numbers times the capacity of your SD card and you'll know the approximate
amount of recording time available. For example, I used a 4GB SanDisk card
at 1080p, which yields approximately 48 minutes of recording.
Here's a snipped screen shot of the file size comparison. The Drift
X170 and GoPro HD were mounted on either side of the fuel tank on the motorcycle
with suction cup mounts and the cameras were started more or less within a few
seconds of each other and turned off about the same times.
The Drift X170 is not HD and saves files in .MP4 or .MJPEG .avi format, so you can see the
difference in file size of the two nearly identical videos:
The GoPro HD camera sits inside the standard GoPro waterproof
housing, which is claimed waterproof to 60 meters, an excellent rating for this
type of unit (the Drift X170 is waterproof to 0.5 meter only). The housing opens easily and it has a thick gasket around
the door. The camera body slides out of the housing and then looks
somewhat forlorn, like a
turtle without its shell, weak and fragile.
Basically anything that was said about the GoPro video cameras
in previous webBikeWorld reviews goes for the HD version also. Not much if anything has
changed -- for better or worse.
The form factor of the GoPro camera inside
the housing has some good points but it can be clumsy to mount on a helmet or a
bike, especially with the included but puzzling suction cup mount that only
articulates in one plane (discussed below).
But overall the package does feel rugged and once the camera is inside
the housing, it seems pretty secure and the housing also offers a extra modicum
of protection for the lens. Remember that the camera must be removed from
the housing to access the ports or the SD card, so be careful to not touch the
coated lens and also to make sure no dirt, moisture, salt water or sand gets inside.
Battery and Charging
The GoPro HD uses a lithium ion battery with a claimed 2.25 hours
recording time vs. 4.5 hours claimed for the two AA batteries in the Drift X170.
The camera must be removed from the housing and connected
via the supplied USB cable to a computer or a powered USB hub for recharging,
which can be a problem because then the camera is sitting out in the open,
increasing the potential for dust or dirt intrusion or a tip-over which might
damage the lens.
In comparison, the Drift X170 uses two AA batteries, which I
think is a better
solution because the batteries can be replaced on the road if necessary.
The X170 comes with a couple of basic Maxell alkalines, but rechargeable
batteries can be used also and lithium batteries are recommended.
Both the GoPro HD and the Drift X170 have battery life
indicators on their LCD panels.
It takes about 4 hours to completely recharge the GoPro HD when
using a computer USB port. Accessory chargers are available which can
decrease this time, but if the battery dies whilst you're on the road, you're sunk,
unless you have a spare battery or a plug-in 12V recharger with a USB connector.
The internal
battery in the GoPro is replaceable and a spare can be purchased from GoPro for $19.99 (we
previously were incorrect in reporting that the battery was permanent).
Both the GoPro HD and the Drift X170 can be powered
from an accessory (i.e., cigarette lighter socket) power supply that converts to
a USB output (like these car chargers with USB cable on Amazon.com)
and the GoPro battery would be charged when doing so. However, the GoPro
would have to be removed from its housing to do so and the rear battery
compartment door on the Drift camera would have to be open to connect to the USB
port.
wBW Flash Slide Show: GoPro HD and Drift X170 Photos.
About That Box...
I want to tell you about a pet peeve of mine that relates to both of
these cameras. They both came in boxes that are basically completely
useless once opened.
The GoPro HD box is especially bad in this regard, as
it has a clear plastic top that serves no functional purpose after it is ripped
off the top of the cardboard container. The worst part about it is that
the plastic isn't even made from a recyclable type of material.
The Drift X170 box isn't much better, filled with a big EPS foam
insert. Once you remove all the parts from either box -- and there are a
lot of parts and accessories -- you're stuck with a pile of stuff that needs to
be stored somewhere.
So why can't these companies create packaging that serves a dual
purpose? A nice container or soft pack that holds all the goodies, with
the company logo on the outside that would protect the camera and the lens, help the environment (potentially) and
give the owner something to carry all the gear around in? To me, it's a
natural, and why they haven't done this is a mystery.
All of the parts provided with the GoPro HD camera.
In the Box
The GoPro HD comes with a large assortment of accessories,
including one of the most important: a suction cup mount. It's a nice
mount; the Drift X170 does not come with one, so I had to buy a separate Panavise-type similar mount for that camera for about $25.00.
The GoPro HD Motorsports version includes the suction cup mount,
several mount adapters, sticky helmet mounts (curved and flat) and the USB and
video cables that end up in the drawer.
It's all enough to get you going, but the standard GoPro suction
cup mount, although of good quality, does not have a ball joint. This is a
definite oversight, because the mount that's provided with the unit bends in
only one plane, which can make for
a difficult proposition to get the camera situated perfectly to take the video.
I won't list all the included bits in detail because that
information is readily available on the GoPro or retailers' websites.
Suffice it to say that you'll pretty much have everything you need to start
recording right out of the box. I have not used any of the accessories
other than the suction cup mount, on which I immediately mounted the camera and
it hasn't come off since.
The GoPro HD is inserted into the waterproof housing.
GoPro HD File Format
I went on quite a bit about the QuickTime format used in the
VholdR ContourHD
(review) video camera I reviewed not too long ago. The GoPro has no
such issues; it uses the widely accepted and high-quality .MP4 format using H.264 video
compression standard and the files are easily read on the two computers and one
laptop used during the evaluation.
The .MP4 files were imported into with Adobe Premiere Elements 8.01 with no
problems and were easily edited. After editing, the files were saved again
in H.264 format and uploaded to YouTube.
We created two short videos (below); one
is a quick overview of the cameras and the other is a brief comparison of the
videos taken in the studio and on the road with both the GoPro HD and the Drift
X170.
The studio videos compare the quality of the Canon HV20 video camera we use
for most of the webBikeWorld videos (1080i) with the GoPro HD and the Drift
X170. You will see in the videos that the Canon still has much better
quality, while the GoPro produces good quality video but the very wide angle
lens that somewhat distorts the perspective, especially at close range, while
the Drift X170 is wide angle only.
The GoPro lens is a fixed f2.8 and the field of view is 170 degrees for 720p
or 960p, while the 1080p has a field of view of 127 degrees.
The fixed f-stop and the comparatively crude firmware has occasional
difficulties with high-contrast scenes, or when coming from shadows to sunlight
when riding and shooting a video. Both of those cameras also have lower
quality, less saturation and lower contrast levels than the Canon and are lower
quality than even most of the relatively inexpensive digital cameras with HD
video capability, so we still have a way to go in this area.
Still Image Lens Perspective Comparison:
Left - Nikon D70, 18-200VR at 35 mm. Center - Drift X170.
Right - GoPro HD.
Here is a 625
pixel wide version of this comparison. Photos unretouched but cropped
to 625 pixels.
Notes on Using the GoPro HD One big difference between the GoPro series of cameras and the Drift
X170 is that the Drift has a live view on a built-in LCD color screen.
This immediately makes the tiny black-and-white, not-live screen on the GoPro
obsolete and looking like something from the early 1980's.
The Drift has an easy-to-use menu system and being able to see the live view
immediately in the screen allows the user to line up the camera and know exactly
what will be recorded. The GoPro user is completely blind -- you're
setting up the camera, hoping that you'll record what it's pointing at.
The GoPro LCD screen is tiny, at 12 by 15 mm. As a result, the menu
system is very cryptic, with very low resolution letters and numbers used.
It looks like a screen from "Pong", a 1970's video game.
We found that we had to carry the instruction sheet as a reminder of all the
different settings. Also, missing a menu choice means going through the
entire system again, selecting each choice until you return to where you were.
There is no "back" button. The Drift X170 menu is worlds apart, with color
and ease of use that again make the GoPro system seem antique.
It can be quite frustrating and several videos we took were not recorded
correctly because the camera simply wasn't pointing in the direction we thought
it was. This could be at least somewhat corrected if GoPro had a built-in
laser pointer, or a mechanical eye port that somehow attached to the camera to
allow it to be aligned correctly.
Also, it appears that both of these cameras do not have an obvious warning if
no SD card is installed. We tried taking videos several times and couldn't
figure out what was going on until we realized the memory card was not
installed. There should be a very obvious warning, flashing lights and
beeps if the camera is turned on without the memory card.
The GoPro does not have a 1/4-20 adapter built-in either, which is a must on
any type of camera. The 1/4-20 tripod mount thread has been used for
decades as the standard for cameras of all types and its absence makes the
cameras more difficult to use. The Drift X170 does have a built-in metal
1/4-20 thread.
However, the suction cup mount provided with our GoPro HD does not have a
ball mount, so it can only be used in one plane, which can be frustrating when
trying to line up the camera, especially since you can't tell exactly where the
camera is pointing. The combination of the poorly designed suction cup
mount with no ball head and the difficulty in lining up the camera (no live
view) is frustrating.
The GoPro video does have some of the "rolling shutter" or "wavy" effect that
is characteristic of CMOS sensors. You can see this effect in the on-bike
video. It takes decent still photos also, albeit with the wide-angle,
somewhat distorted perspective due to the fixed lens.
The Opinionator -
GoPro HD Hero Video Camera
Picks...
...and Pans.
Relatively good quality video.
Good selection of accessories.
Very waterproof housing.
Decent suction cup mount
included.
Takes decent still photos.
Relatively expensive for what it
is.
Video not as good as a
similarly-priced digital camera.
Single plane articulation on
suction cup mount can be frustrating.
Menu system seems obsolete.
No live view.
Sound Recording
The GoPro HD has a built-in microphone that at least
records higher quality sound than the VholdR ContourHD.
The GoPro comes with a separate open back for the
housing that can be used to allow better access to the
microphone, but using the open back obviously makes it
non-waterproof or even water-resistant.
We left the sound unchanged and unedited in the on-bike video samples.
With careful placement and possibly some wind-filtering experimentation, the
sound may be better than we recorded, but we didn't spend much time trying to
perfect this aspect of the cameras. Some owners report success using
different types of open-cell foam strategically placed over the microphone.
wBWVideo:
Part 1: GoPro HD and Drift X170 Quick Walk-Through
wBWVideo: Part 2: GoPro HD and Drift X170
Studio and On-Bike Video Comparison
NOTE: The raw files were processed in
Adobe Premier Elements 8.0 and exported as H.264 in .M2T
format. The files are compressed again when
uploaded to YouTube, so the quality is slightly degraded
from the original video.
NEW
Video!Riding
the Harley-Davidson Road Glide Custom (YouTube video). A video
taken with the GoPro HD (user selectable for various HD resolutions in the
YouTube drop-down). Added May 18, 2010.
Conclusion
Not sure what else I can tell you about the GoPro HD
video camera that hasn't already been covered in the
webBikeWorld reviews of the GoPro original and GoPro
Wide reviews. If you have any other questions,
feel free to send them to the Editor and I'll try to
answer in the Owner Comments section below.
The GoPro HD does take decent video and it's certainly a positive evolution
of the original GoPro cameras. The form factor can be a slight problem but
it's more subjective so the owner will have to decide if the bulkiness of the
GoPro is something that will work for their particular usage. It works
best when attached to the suction mount and then to the side of the motorcycle
or top of the helmet, although the lack of a ball head on the mount can be a
problem, but not a deal-killer.
If the Drift X170 had full HD, it would probably be a clear winner in this
comparison, unless you needed the full waterproof capability of the GoPro.
I'd bet that Drift will have an HD version sometime soon. In the meantime,
the GoPro probably does have what is currently the best cost/quality ratio of
any of the small "adventure" type outdoors video cameras.
Please
send
comments to
Comments are ordered from most recent to oldest.
Not all comments will be published (details). Comments may be edited for
clarity prior to publication.
From "G.E." (8/10): "I just read your GoPro HD review after
reading your Drift HD170 review... You should be aware that there are some
significant problems with the GoPro HD that you may want to add to your review,
these problems are detailed in the unofficial GoPro forums at
goprouser.freeforums.org.
Issue #1, no upside down mode which was a listed feature when they had the
pre-order last fall, just empty promises on fixing it.
Issue #2, there is a problem with several name brand SDHC cards where the camera
will not continue writing files after the 4GB limit when recording in the R3
mode. This mostly happens with cards that are 16GB and larger, even the
cards that GoPro sells.
Issue #3, if you use the time lapse still picture modes, you will soon render
your camera non-functional. There is a bug that makes the camera stop
working after 9999 images or files are made, it is easy to hit this with time
lapse. The only fix is to return the camera to GoPro, and then it starts
all over again.
Issue #4, many of these cameras have a annoying rattle which comes from the top
shutter button. It's a mechanical problem that needs to be addressed.
They keep stringing users on with the saying that the firmware will be coming
soon, it has been coming soon since I inquired back in November one day after I
received my camera and found that the setting was not present.
Just thought this should be added to the review so that anyone reading the
review and buying the camera will know what they are getting into."
From "M.G." (4/10): "I recently read your review about the
GoPro HD and Drift X170. At one point you noted that you preferred using
AA replaceable batteries over the GoPro's lithium-ion because they can be easily
swapped out. I have to disagree.
I own both the original GoPro (none-widescreen) and the current HD model.
My biggest annoyance with the original was being forced to use AAA batteries
that rarely lasted longer than an hour, and quickly drained on their own
(meaning your back-ups may be dead).
In contrast, the GoPro HD has a battery life indicator on the screen, and the
lithium battery lasts more than long enough. Furthermore, GoPro sells
extra lithium batteries that can be swapped in if the original while on the
road. And they're planning on including a software upgrade via their
website to let you charge the camera while it records, theoretically making
battery life infinite.
I also noticed a dramatic increase in the audio quality from the original GoPro
to the HD. The non-waterproof backing to the case makes a big difference.
This may be an issue in more tropical climates where rain comes without warning,
but in arid areas it works great.
Editor's Reply: A few points of clarification: The
article was revised since the original to note that the battery in the GoPro HD
is replaceable. A new battery sells for $19.99 on the GoPro website but
may be a bargain, depending on how many times it can be recharged vs.
rechargeable AA batteries.
The Drift uses AA batteries, not AAA. The AA batteries in the Drift last a
claimed 4.5 hours, compared to a claimed 2.5 hours for the lithium battery in
the GoPro HD. So a pair of AA batteries last nearly twice as long as the
lithium battery in the GoPro, but it's probably not a fair comparison because
the video types are different.
There is also the convenience factor because AA batteries are readily
available when traveling. Both the Drift and the GoPro have a battery life
indicator.
As was mentioned in the article, both cameras can be powered via a USB port and
the GoPro batteries are recharged when doing this. However, connecting a USB
cable means removing the camera from its waterproof housing.
