|
Motorcycle Lift
Sears Craftsman Motorcycle Jack Stand
wBW
Reviews Home
|
Comments From Owners (Below)
Just about every motorcycle I've ever owned had a center stand. When I
purchased the Triumph Thunderbird Sport shown here, it crossed my mind that the lack of a center
stand might be a problem, but my emotions took over and I bought the bike
anyway.
I love the bike, but after living with it for a while, I've come to the
conclusion that every motorcycle should have a center
stand as original equipment, no doubt about it.
I had no idea how hard it would be to perform the most basic
maintenance tasks on a motorcycle sans center stand. Easy projects
like an engine oil or fork oil change, a chain lube, tire
change or even cleaning the wheels are more difficult or, in some cases,
nearly impossible without extra lifts, stands or jacks.
A rear swingarm (aka paddock) stand, like the Steel Horse unit that
can just be seen in these photos (see the wBW
review of the Steel Horse
swingarm stand) is a must-have for a motorcycle without a center stand.
But even the Steel Horse stand can't help when it comes to front end work.
I cobbed together a wooden box-like structure that I used to place under the
engine to hold the Triumph steady for front end work, along with the
swingarm stand holding up the rear. But it's very hard to balance
the Triumph's engine over the wooden structure.
It would take me longer to get the bike set up on the box than it would to
remove the front wheel, and I never felt safe doing it. This job
should be a no-brainer with a center stand, as it is on my BMW R65.
The Sears Craftsman "Motorcycle/ATV Jack" stand has been available
for a couple of years, and I had it in the back of my mind that one day I'd
buy one when it was on
sale. When this product first came out, it was selling for something
like $149.95.
The price has dropped to around $119.00, and it can
occasionally
found on sale for $99.00. I belong to the
Craftsman Tool Club, which means an extra 10% discount during the frequent Tool Club
sale
weeks. Sears was having a sale recently on the jack for
$90.00, and with my discount, I ended up paying right around 80 bucks.
The Sears motorcycle jack (or motorcycle lift, as I prefer to call it) comes
packed in a hefty box. The unit weighs in at 90
pounds. Some assembly with a 14 mm wrench is required, but the instructions are rather straightforward (if a bit sparse
in detail) and the unit can be assembled in about
10 minutes or so with frequent references to the line drawings printed in
the instruction manual.
Using the Motorcycle Lift
The basic concept is to slide the lift under the motorcycle, lock the two
revolving rear wheels and slowly jack up the bike by pressing on the foot
pedal that operates the hydraulic jack. There are two vinyl
coated parallel lifting surfaces that contact the underside of the bike or
engine and lift straight up. They don't lift in a precisely vertical
plane; there is some sideways movement, but it's easy enough to compensate
for the drift.
We found that the lift works best when the motorcycle is positioned
vertically with the rear end up on a swingarm stand. There are way too
many motorcycle configurations for us to try, but for the most part, if you
don't own a swingarm stand, the motorcycle should be parked nearly vertical
with something like a piece of wood under the side stand to minimize lean.
If you can do this, AND if you have enough clearance under the right side of
the motorcycle without fouling the exhausts, the lift can be pushed under
the engine from the side of the bike opposite the side stand.
The jack is released by lightly stepping on the release pedal. The
lift is designed to hold a maximum of 1,500 pounds, according to Sears,
which should be enough for just about any motorcycle out there.
The
lift has a built-in safety feature, which is basically a pair of spring-loaded
ratchet levers that can be placed in one of 3 positions to prevent the jack
from collapsing (see photo, left). The knobs on the right in the
photo can be screwed down to the floor to help steady the lift.
It all works very smoothly, and I was impressed at the accurate feel of the
pedals when lifting or releasing the bike. Very accurate positioning
can be obtained, so the hydraulic cylinder must be specially designed for
this application.
The lift works much better under a motorcycle with a pair of full-length
frame tubes, like most cruisers and many older bikes. The Triumph, however,
uses its engine as a stressed member, and there are no frame rails
underneath. We did not try using the lift under a sportbike, but I
think a horizontal four-cylinder engine might be too narrow (front to back)
to fit on the lift's rails.
The short length of the Triumph's engine means that the lift must be precisely centered under the engine
to balance
the motorcycle on the stand. The only point of contact on this bike is
the oil pan, which is very narrow.
The Thunderbird Sport's exhaust hangs off
the right side and sits slightly lower than the engine, so the use of a
swingarm stand is a must and the lift must be
rolled under the left side of the bike. This is something to consider
if you plan on purchasing a lift. The Triumph's engine is just barely wide
and long enough for the lift to fit underneath, and the bike
will balance on the lift's pads, but just barely.
The lift easily slides underneath most motorcycles, because it collapses to
5-1/4" high under the lifting surfaces. Sears recommends raising the lift
to one of the 3 safety catch levels only, which
engage at 11-3/4", 14-1/4" and 16-1/2" high.
The problem, at least with a motorcycle without under-engine frame rails
like the Thunderbird Sport, is that the balance point (of the motorcycle) is
located in a very narrow window,
both front-to-back and side-to-side. Sears provides two ratcheting
tie-downs in the box (which can also be used to tie down the bike on a
trailer or pickup truck bed). The tie-downs attach to one of four
welded-on points on the frame of the lift.
But the tie-downs don't really do much to hold the bike. They'll hold
the bike to the lift, but if the whole shebang decides to topple over, the
straps will probably do nothing other than keep the lift attached to the
bottom of the bike.
When the bike is on the lift in the raised position, it's
steady enough to do some minor repair like an oil change or cleaning, but most of the time if you need to
lift a motorcycle, it's for some heavy work, like removing the front tire or
forks.
After
trying the lift under a couple of motorcycles, I'm not convinced that it
will hold a motorcycle steady enough to perform anything other than very
light maintenance. The bikes just seem too unsteady and the balance point is too sensitive.
I can easily rock a motorcycle back and forth or side to side when it's on
the lift, so I would
certainly expect it to fall over backwards if, for example, the weight of
the front tire is removed.
I don't think the Triumph could be successfully balanced on the lift without
the front wheel, because the engine is not wide enough front to back to
allow the lift to be relocated to account for the lighter weight.
There's only one location where the lift will fit, and it doesn't take much
to unbalance the bike when it's raised.
The two vinyl coated parallel lift surfaces are 13-1/4" wide to the outer
edges, and each flat is 2-1/2" wide. This means that if your engine is
shorter (front to back) than the lifting surfaces are wide, there many not
be any leeway for adjusting the position of the lift to stabilize the bike
under various weighting scenarios.
My opinion is that a motorcycle on this lift may not be safe enough to
perform anything other than light maintenance. For example, the front
axle nuts on the Triumph take some muscle to remove, and that kind of
jerking around could upset
the balance. Your fear factor may vary; I'm conservative when it comes
to working around heavy machinery.
Conclusion
My opinion is that the product is definitely not a replacement for a proper
motorcycle table lift, nor is it a replacement for a rear swingarm stand. It does work better on motorcycles with frame
rails underneath, like those found on most cruisers. However, the potential problem
of side-to-side and front-to-back balance still exists. The
motorcycles we tried just seem too unbalanced for me to feel comfortable.
I'm not sure
what types of maintenance jobs the lift is designed for. An oil
change, perhaps, or maybe to clean the wheels?
If anyone has experience using the Sears motorcycle lift and is interested
in relating their experiences, send me an email to
and I'll
post your comments.
|
Sears Craftsman Motorcycle Jack Stand
Review |
| Available
From:
Sears
Item #:
00950190000
|
Suggested
Retail Price: Can be found
on sale for $80.00 with Sears Tool Club membership (free).
Made In: China |
| Product
Comments: Works well but is
not a replacement for a proper motorcycle lift table. It
may be hard to find a safe balance point on some motorcycles. |
Note: For informational use only. All material and
photographs are Copyright © webWorld International, LLC - 2000-2011. All
rights reserved. See the webBikeWorld®
Site Info
page. NOTE: Product specifications, features and details may
change or differ from our descriptions. Always check before purchasing. Read
the
Terms and Conditions!
Comments from Owners
Editor's Note: Many cruisers have
double-cradle frames, which work much better with the
Sears lift because the bike sits on the lift via the
frames looping under the engine. Motorcycles
without frames looping under the engine have a much
smaller surface to sit on the lift; in some cases, the
entire motorcycle must be balanced on its oil pan.
This can cause an unstable platform for serious work.
From "D.K.": "I've owned this
lift for 3 or 4 years now. I regularly lift my 850
pound Harley-Davidson Electra Glide. I use it to
change tires, brakes, etc... I also use it to
level the bike for general maintenance since H-D does
not have a center stand. It's also nice to raise
it up and sit on my wheeled stool for cleaning and
maintenance.
I have not had a problem with the jack. I
always set the lock bar and throw a ratchet strap over
the frame spine of the bike for safety. When I
remove one of the wheels I place a jack stand at the
other end. Thanks for a great and useful article.
BTW - as of this writing the jack is on sale for $69.99
at sears.com. The sears web site has customer
reviews posted. Most of the complaints are of
bottle jack failures. Sounds like they need to
heed S.P.'s advice (see comment below)."
From "P.": "Read your review of the
Sears motorcycle lift. I have what I believe is
the same lift, but sold by Harbor Freight. It's
made in China, appears rather crude but identical to the
lift in your pictures. I bought it from a fellow
on Craigslist for $35, to work on my Suzuki DR650 dual
sport bike (about 350 lbs.). I've used the stand
to lift the bike while I straightened the forks (twisted
in a fall due to ice) and to lube the chain, and intend
to use it for oil changes and further maintenance.
The bike is quite stable when lifted, the stand works
fine for me."
From: "S.P.": "I've had mine for
about a year now and it has malfunctioned twice.
The rubber plug leaks and a threaded plug would be
desired, but wall thinness may prohibit this. Plug
access is a pain as it's location is under the return
spring and on the side, rather than on top when the jack
is fully retracted. Going to wrap electric tape
around the jack, covering the plug to see if this helps
...poor design.
When it works it is a back saver. I have a
classic GT750 and doing the points and timing on the
jack is very convenient. Or any maintenance on the
carbs, air cleaner, etc. Anything to keep me out
of a unright fetal position is a plus. Got spokes
to polish rims to clean ...on the jack it goes."
Update From "S.P.": "I
finally found the reason my Sears Motorcycle jack keeps
failing and is probably the same issue on some of the
other responders issues with this jack. The oil
fill plug does not vent properly. As the jack is
raised a vacuum develops in the outer chamber causing a
pressure differential great enough to overcome the ball
valve seating. Oil will not feed to the piston and
the jack feels like it's low on oil.
Put more oil into the jack (removing the
plug (and the pressure differential along with it) and
it may start working again but the plug (and extra oil)
will blow out the fill hole when retracting the jack.
Making a #$%^ mess.
Replacing the rubber plug with a 5/16" grommet,
inserting a plastic tube to fill the grommet hole (and
provide a positive vent) enables the jack to work
flawlessly, full piston strokes to the full height of
the ram. Hope this alleviates someone else's
frustration, a $0.43 fix."
From "D.F.": "I ride a 2003 V-Star
650 - I lowered the rear 4-5" and the forks are 2"
longer, thus reducing the ground clearance. After
these modifications I bought this lift from Canadian
Tire, apparently for $102.59 including tax. These
modifications prevent the lift from easily sliding under
the bike, but a 2 x 4 plank under each wheel provided
the required clearance. I found the lift arms were
not horizontal, in fact I needed to shim them up at the
end furthest from the hydraulic cylinder. In fact
I had to shim up both sides (of each arm) in order for
the belly of the motor to clear the lift. Setting up the
lift is time consuming to be sure.
However, once the bike is off the ground I was
comfortable working on the bike, although mindful of the
big picture. Most recently I removed my rear
wheel/hub/driveshaft/fender while using the lift.
Worked great. Incidentally. there is no rule book
associated with this lift so that said, I added
additional load carrying/stabilizing components (more
wood) to steady the bike (photos below). Weighing
the significant factors I believe this lift is the best
bang for the buck."
From "G.S.": "Firstly, congrats on a
magic site. I own a Harley Heritage and as Harley
heads do, I needed to clean the spoked wheels.
This was only possible with some sort of jack. I
got onto the web and found the plans for the jack and
built myself a basic jack that worked really well.
I then thought that it would be better to get hold of a
commercially available one from Sears that had all the
bells and whistles. This I did at great expense,
only to find that the Sears jack was at best, extremely
unstable and the bike did not look safe at all.
The jack is not well made and the width has not been
very well thought out."
From "K.W.": "I tried the same model as you
and also the new aluminum model and had to return both.
The all metal model was no where near what I would call
a safe device to use for anything other then cleaning
etc.
The other problem was, I have a Victory TC and the
distance between the frames are approximately 13".
This does not leave a lot of room for error as the
lifting plates are only 13.5" on both models.
However, the aluminum model was a little more stable on
a test bike (Honda Shadow) that I used. I could've
reworked the all aluminum one and added another 1" to
each end of the lifting plate, but here your getting
into changing stress points as well as balance points.
So I opted not to do that.
So I'm currently trying to gather information on the
OTC Model 1545 lift that has 17" lift plates. The
whole process is problematic when you have to purchase
on line. If the product does not measure up to be
sound and safe then you end up eating the shipping
charges back to the supplier. So I send quite a
few emails inquiring about the product first.
If it wasn't for people like you with reviews, it
would be worse then what it is. This I thank you
for."
From "J.B.": "I paid even less for the
jack - I borrow my friends. :) I ride a Triumph
Bonneville America and I've used the Sears jack for major
operations like removing the wheels to take them in to the
shop for new tires (saves me $50 per wheel) and last year I
replaced the chain and sprockets with a QPD belt drive,
necessitating the removal of the rear swing arm. I do
use the straps but it seems to me this is akin to putting
your arm in a sling - it's not really there to help keep
your arm safe as much as it is there to *remind* you to
watch out for it.
I agree that the jack seems unstable but it's really
not once you understand the balance point concept. I suppose the
true novice could get into trouble with it but it has handled
everything I've thrown at it just fine. Considering it costs a
small fraction of the cost of a "proper motorcycle lift," its the
only realistic option for many enthusiasts who want to do their own
maintenance."
From "B.C.": "I have
used this lift for 2 years for winter storage of my
Honda Valkyrie interstate. (There is an adaptor
made for the Valk). My bike is the Blue silver
Interstate. Tires, brakes, oil change, etc. have all
been done on this lift. Very stable for a big
bike."
From "P.A.": "I too
purchased the sears lift for about $80. I
assembled it and was a little skeptical about lifting
Goldwings. I have two 1500 models and it worked
great. I had to leave the center stand up and
place it as close as possible to it. It was a
tight fit sliding it underneath from the right side but
it does go if the side stand is propped up slightly.
I did extensive maintenance to the one bike ( front
wheel and forks removed, rear wheel removed along with
the trunk and bags. As I was working on it I was a
little fearful at first but as the worked progressed the
bike was much more stable than I anticipated.
After awhile, I had complete faith in it and did not
even think about the jack while performing the work. It
was money well spent. I am 100% satisfied knowing
it has some limitations but does what I need it to do." |