|
Shark RSR Helmet
by Rick K. for webBikeWorld.com
More: wBW
Reviews Home
| Shark RSI
Here's a motorcycle helmet trivia question: What to these
motorcycle racers have in common?
MotoGP racers Alex Barros, Olivier
Jacque and Jeremy McWilliams; World Superbike racers Chris Walker, Regis Laconi, Gregorio Lavilla and Troy Corser; World Supersport racers Stephan
Chambon and Karl Muggeridge....
There's more: Arnaud Vincent and Randy DePuniet in 250cc; Pablo Nieto in 125cc; David Vuillemin in Motocross.
I could go on and on. What do they
all have in common?
You've probably guessed by now - they all wear Shark motorcycle helmets!
Shark helmets have been very popular with motorcycle racers, but the
brand has also been a best seller in Europe for some time. Shark
helmets have recently been introduced in the U.S.A., and we obtained their top-of-the-line
model, the RSR, for this review.
Shark is serious about the U.S.
market, and they went through the trouble of obtaining a Snell
certification for almost their entire helmet line. Not that a Snell
approval is any better or worse than an ECE 22-05 approval, in our opinion, but it
does give many U.S. riders a sense of security and it also shows commitment
to the U.S. market.
It is said that "racing improves the breed", and Shark has focused on
motorcycle racing as the primary motivator for their designs and technology.
The RSR's shell is made from a "multi-axial fiber structure", composed of a
composite of carbon fiber,
Dyneema, Aramid
fibers and epoxy resin.
Dyneema is claimed to be "the world's strongest
fiber" and who are we to argue? The bottom line is that the Shark RSR
is light yet it has enough guts to meet the world's toughest
motorcycle helmet safety standards, as demonstrated by its ECE 22-05, Snell and DOT
approvals.
All this technology doesn't come cheap -- the Shark RSR lists at nearly
$700.00, which is more than some motorcycle riders will pay for a lifetime
of helmets. Is it worth it? Only you can decide,
but we're going to do something a little different here and start with our
conclusion first: the Shark RSR is hereby designated as webBikeWorld's
"Helmet of the Year"! I know, it's a bit late in the season, but it's
taken almost a year to find one worthy enough!
The Shark RSR puts it all together in a wonderful package that includes
very high quality construction, a supremely comfortable liner, very good air
flow, light weight, relative quiet, a large selection of colors and graphics and, of course, the heretofore mentioned
safety approvals. The agreement here at webBikeWorld is unanimous:
if we had to own only a single helmet, the Shark RSR would be it.
That's not to say that it doesn't have a couple of faults: after all,
the perfect helmet doesn't exist...yet. But read on and we'll explain.
Paint and Graphics
Motorcycle helmet manufacturers use all sorts of acronyms and mumbo-jumbo to
describe their helmet shell compositions. The very low end helmets use
polycarbonate, while the more expensive and/or race helmets use various
proprietary blends of exotic fibers. If a helmet meets the various
safety tests, it's hard for an owner to know if one material will protect
any better than the
other.
And some helmet manufacturers use high-tech blends to construct
their helmet shells and still end up with a heavy helmet, so who knows
what's best? But the exotic fibers used in the RSR seem to have done
their job, because the helmet weighs in at 1601 grams for a size XL (3 lbs.,
8-1/2 oz.), which makes it the lightest Snell, DOT and ECE 22-05 approved
helmet we've found.
Motorcycle helmet manufacturers have told us that helmets meeting the
Snell certification are usually heavier than their ECE 22-05 only
counterparts. Apparently, there's a Snell penetration test that isn't
included in ECE 22-05. To pass the Snell test, the helmet shell
usually must be thicker, adding weight. But Shark has managed to pass
the test with a minimal weight difference, so their fiber mix must be doing
its stuff.
The finish and graphics on the RSR are very good. Not quite
perfect, because there are a few very tiny bumps that can be seen under
close inspection under the decals, but the overall impression is one of
quality. The paint and clear coat is very good, not quite as thick as
the other ultra-high-end helmet we've reviewed,
Schuberth's S1, but no one
would no the difference unless they're compared side-by-side. Shark offers
many different race replicas, so it should be easy to find a color and
graphic pattern that tickles your fancy.
The Shark RSR has a few added-on vent trim parts that leave small gaps
where they're mounted to the helmet shell, and we've noticed that these gaps
seem to attract insects and dirt during a ride. This makes the helmet
harder to clean than others, but the gaps are the only flaw in the overall
finish and they don't seem to have affected the overall integrity of the
helmet.
Visor
The RSR's visor looks thick because it is. At 3 mm, it's one of the
heftiest used on any motorcycle helmet. It has excellent optical
qualities, and it includes an anti-fog coating.
The
visor
doesn't use the typical molded-in click stops to hold open the visor at
various settings. The RSR's visor is infinitely adjustable up and down
within its range. The amount of force that is necessary to raise or
lower the visor is adjustable via the hex screw in the center of the comma-shaped
"safety lever" on each side (yellow arrow, photo left). The safety
lever also holds the visor in place in the unlikely event of a failure of
the visor release mechanism.
The mechanism used for rotation and removal of the visor is unique. To
remove the visor, first turn the safety latch so that it lines up with the
slit cut into the visor. Flip open the round visor removal latch (pink
arrow, photo left) and give it a 1/4-turn twist, and the visor pops off.
This unique removal mechanism is more complex than other helmets, but it
works well and the metal parts seem like they'll last forever.
The visor removal latch is very stiff, so it's hard to lift with a
fingernail, but a coin will do the trick. We're not sure if it will
loosen up over time; probably not, because the only time it's used is when
the visor needs replacement. The visor has tear-off posts attached,
and Shark includes a few tear-offs in the package.
We really like the visor's friction locating system, which allows it to be
raised and lowered to any location and not just to the half-dozen or so
fixed click stops found in other visor systems. The RSR has a small
indent built into the shell under the left hand side of the visor which
works as a place to slide in a finger to push open the visor. The
thickness of the visor prevents it from twisting when it's pushed up with
one finger.
Venting
The RSR has the typical venting combination of chin inlet and top inlet with
rear exhaust vents. The chin inlet opens with an easy to use slide
mechanism; push it up and down to open or close. The air from this
vent flows up on to the back of the visor and on to the rider's face.
It provides a good amount of air flow and the slider has a positive feel.
The top vent is the most distinctive feature of the RSR. It's a big,
it's round and it has "in-your-face" styling. It probably wouldn't be
as noticeable if it wasn't emphasized by the various trim pieces that
surround it.
A slider on top opens or closes the vent in a positive manner. The
vent provides a decent amount of air flow across the rider's head. It's
about as much air flowing through the top of a helmet as we've experienced;
only the OGK FF-3, which is unfortunately no longer available, has better
air flow in our opinion (see
the wBW review).
The rear exhaust vent is located in back of the spoiler on top of the
helmet. A simple on/off switch opens or closes the exhaust, but as
with most rear exhaust vents, it's hard to tell whether it's working or not.
The RSR also has small single vent on each side on the lower part of the
shell.
The volume of air flow through the RSR is probably enhanced by its special
foam liner. The liner has deep grooves running longitudinally from
front to back, and the top of the fabric helmet liner is designed to
"float", allowing lots of air to run over the top of the rider's head.
Fit
It's often hard to tell the difference in helmet liner comfort, no matter
what the manufacturer's marketing hype would like you to believe.
Unless the liner is made from a very rough fabric or if it's thin enough to
allow the parts of the shell to be felt, just about any liner will offer
acceptable comfort. But the RSR's liner is truly different; not only
is the fabric very soft, with a feel almost like soft Chamois cloth, but the
squishy padding is form-fitting and comfortable.
The RSR will probably fit round shaped heads best. It is designed to
have a very snug fit, which is normal for racing helmets. Our opinion
is that the RSR runs at least one size small; i.e., you may want to order
one size larger than normal.
I have an "earth" shaped head (see the wBW
Motorcycle Helmet FAQ page for more information on helmet fit) and the
RSR is one of the most comfortable helmets I've tried, with one exception.
The cheek pads cause some discomfort at my temporomandibular joint (jaw
joint) after about an hour or so. Shark has an extensive list of
replacement parts for the RSR (available via download in .pdf format on
their website), so I plan on ordering a new set of thinner cheek pads, which
I'm sure will fix this problem.
But overall, the combination of the squishy padding and comfortable liner
makes the RSR feel like it was custom-tailored just for me.
Weight
We've addressed this above; make sure you check out the wBW
Motorcycle Helmet FAQ page, where you'll find a chart that compares the
weight of some of the motorcycle helmets that we've reviewed. Note
that Shark uses two different shell sizes, and the XL and XXL weigh slightly
more than the smaller sizes.
Noise
It may be because of the snug fit, or the form-fitting liner, but our
opinion is that the Shark RSR is a relatively quiet helmet for its type.
Note that we always wear correctly fitted earplugs whenever we ride (see the
wBW
Earplugs and Hearing
Protection page for more information) and we always wear a helmet liner,
or "do rag".
Shark includes an under-the-chin wind blocker that helps eliminate some of
the low frequency "booming" noises that are typically generated from up
under the neck area of the helmet. We've also found that the
Windjammer Helmet Wind Blocker can help eliminate much of this type of noise
(see the wBW
review).
But overall, the RSR is quieter than other race helmets, and only has a
"whooshing" noise that is generated through the large vent openings.
Miscellaneous
Shark includes both summer and winter breath guards that can be attached to
the helmet. The summer breath guard is a small piece that slips in
behind the vent that opens on to the back of the visor. The winter
breath guard is a large piece of material that snaps in to two holes inside
the helmet in the back of the chin guard. A soft metal bar can be bent
to form the piece to the rider's face. Shark also includes a soft
helmet bag with the purchase.
The Shark RSR uses the tried-and-true D-ring attachment system. Our
opinion is that D-rings are the only way to go; we haven't found any type of
"quick release" system that is as simple and works as well as D-rings.
The RSR's strap has the same comfortable padding used in the rest of the
helmet, and there's a snap on the strap end to keep it secure.
Conclusion
The Shark RSR doesn't really break any new ground in helmet design, but its
combination of high-quality finish, very comfortable liner, good air flow
and the ease of use for the visor make it hard to beat.
The RSR stands
out from all of the helmets we've tried this year, so we're awarding it with
our informal webBikeWorld "Motorcycle Helmet of the Year" award. If we
had to choose only a single helmet to wear every day, this would be it.
However, its price means that it's not for everyone. Is it twice as
good as a $300.00 helmet? Probably not.
| Product
Review: Shark RSR Motorcycle Helmet |
|
BUY IT!
Use this
link to get your Shark Helmet at RevZilla and help support
webBikeWorld! |
| Available
From: Shark
Helmets |
Suggested
Retail Price: $699.99 graphics, $592.99 solids. |
| Colors: Many
solids, graphics and replicas. |
Made
in: Thailand (Designed in France) |
| Product
Comments: Expensive, although the RSR can be found for
$550.00 or so at retail. Relatively light weight at 1601 grams (3 lbs.,
8-1/2 oz.) for a size XL. Snell, DOT and ECE 22-05 certified.
Very strong, 3 mm thick visor with great optical quality. Visor
has infinite adjustment for opening and is also adjustable for visor
opening and closing force. Extremely comfortable liner.
Excellent air flow. Uses D-ring attachment with comfortable chin
strap. Relatively quiet. Includes summer and winter breath
guards, tear-offs and under-chin wind blocker. Review Date:
October 2004 |
| More:
Large sized (650x670) photo
of the Shark RSR | Compare the Shark RSR
with the equally expensive Schuberth S1; see the wBW
Schuberth
S1 review |
Comparison: Schuberth vs. Shark |
Note: For informational use only. All material and
photographs are Copyright © webWorld International, LLC - 2000-2011. All
rights reserved. See the webBikeWorld®
Site Info
page. NOTE: Product specifications, features and details may
change or differ from our descriptions. Always check before purchasing. Read
the
Terms and Conditions!
|